Rate this recipe

Frozen
yogurt

Yogurt is sour and naturally quite low in fat, and both work against a creamy texture. The acidity makes it taste refreshingly bright, but without fat, the ice crystals grow unchecked and the mixture turns grainy. So full-fat Greek yogurt, a splash of cream, and enough sugar aren't a luxury here but a necessity. After that, it’s mainly a matter of churning briefly and serving immediately. Serve with a small glass of limoncello or Passoã.

Base: Greek yogurt4 ingredientsGlass: dessert bowl
Frozen yogurt recipe in the right glass
FROZEN YOGURT ✶ GREEK YOGURT ✶ DESSERT BOWL ✶ CHURN & TOP ✶

The frozen yogurt recipe
for your table

How many servings?
Ingredients
1 person
150 gramsfull-fat Greek yogurt, strained
30 gramsfine granulated sugar
25 mlheavy cream, cold from the fridge
5 mllemon juice with a pinch of vanilla
Making frozen yogurt: step by step
1

Hang the yogurt in a clean cloth or in a sieve lined with a coffee filter over a bowl for a few hours. Quite a lot of whey will drain out, leaving a thicker, less watery yogurt. Straining is the cheapest thing you can do to improve the texture.

2

Stir the sugar, lemon juice, and vanilla into the strained yogurt until the sugar has completely dissolved, not just mixed in. Taste it now: everything tastes less sweet when cold, so what tastes just right at room temperature will come out bland from the freezer.

3

Whip the cream until soft peaks form and fold it in in two batches. The fat from the cream settles between the ice crystals and keeps them small. Without the cream, it turns grainy, no matter how carefully you do everything else.

4

Churn the mixture in the ice cream maker, but for less time than you would churn ice cream: it's ready as soon as it reaches the consistency of soft serve. Spoon it straight into the glasses and put the toppings on the table.

What did you think of this recipe?

Just click a star to rate. If you add a comment, we'll review it before it appears here.

Save this recipe

Email the frozen yogurt recipe to yourself, so you'll have it on hand when you're ready to make it. You'll also get a €5 discount code on orders over €50, for the glasses that go with it.

You'll receive the recipe, your discount code and our newsletter with new recipes. You can unsubscribe with one click.

The story

Frozen yogurt isn't ice cream flavored with yogurt; it's the exact opposite: yogurt that you freeze, with just enough cream and sugar added to keep it scoopable. That tartness is the whole point, because it makes the flavor sharper than ice cream and calls for toppings that balance it out. At an ice cream shop, it's held in a machine that keeps it constantly moving and just below freezing, so it stays flowing like soft serve. At home, you don't have that machine, so you make it just before serving and eat it straight away. That's not a drawback; it's simply how the dish works.

The right glass

Frozen yogurt is all about toppings, and that determines the shape of the glass: you want it wide and shallow, so granola, fruit and chocolate sit alongside one another instead of piling up in a funnel. The first glass below holds 18 cl and is described as a wide, low bowl on a low foot, specifically recommended for yogurt with granola and for muesli. The second holds 28 cl and is described as 8.6 cm high with a diameter of 10.9 cm and a sturdy foot. Its clear glass makes the layers of a dessert easy to see. A tall glass looks better in a photo, but you can't reach the bottom properly with a spoon. See more sizes in the ice cream dishes.

Frozen yogurt in a wide 18 cl dessert bowl with vertical ridges, on a low foot
Our pick 01

La Rochere Alice Dessert Bowl 18 cl (6 pieces)

€ 25,95per set · fast delivery on business days
Round footed glass ice cream dish with a red and a green scoop of ice cream and fresh raspberries
Our pick 02

Onis Primavera Ice Cream Dish 28 cl (6 pieces)

€ 25,95per set · fast delivery on business days
Complete set

Both sets together € 51,90.

Shop the combination →

The right tools

For frozen yogurt, besides the glass, use a bar spoon with a long handle to distribute the yogurt to the bottom of a taller glass and a zester to grate chocolate or lemon zest over the toppings. These are the bar tools we use ourselves; find everything in our bar tools & cocktail sets.

Trident bar spoon 30 cm

Distributes the yogurt to the bottom of the glass

€ 12,95
Multifunctional zester

Grates chocolate or lemon zest over the toppings

€ 15,95
Complete in one click

Glassware set (our pick 01) + 2 bar tools together € 54,85.

Everything in the shopping cart →

What to pour alongside it?

A small glass of liqueur with fruit goes better with frozen yogurt than wine, because the tartness of the yogurt calls for something sweet alongside it. Passoã and Malibu pair well with tropical fruit as a topping, while limoncello does the same with lemon. Each drinks page tells you the alcohol percentage, what it tastes like, which cocktails it pairs with, and what glass you need.

Bottle of Passoã 70 cl

types, brands and flavors

Bottle of Passoã 70 cl

around 17% · passion fruit

Bottle of Malibu Coconut 70 cl

around 21% · coconut with a rum base

Bottle of Peachtree 70 cl

around 20% · peach

Bottle of Pallini Limoncello 70 cl

around 26% · ice-cold from the freezer

Bottle of Pallini Limoncello 50 cl

limoncello and other liqueurs

Bottle of Disaronno Originale 70 cl

around 28% · almond and apricot kernels

Variations & twists

Frozen yogurt is as plain as you leave it, because the toppings make the dish. Granola adds the crunch the soft mixture itself lacks, fresh berries and mango bring tartness and sweetness, a spoonful of honey ties it all together, and shaved chocolate stays hard long enough to hear. Want a colorful version? Purée one hundred grams of raspberries or mango, then stir it in with a few strokes at the very end, so streaks remain instead of an even color. There’s also a quick no-machine version: blend frozen fruit with the drained yogurt until thick, and eat it right away. More inspiration? Browse more than 100 cocktail recipes.

Serving tip

Frozen yogurt is at its best straight from the machine, like soft serve. If it has been in the freezer, take the glasses out onto the counter ten minutes before serving, because it gets harder than ice cream. Put the toppings in separate bowls on the table and let everyone build their own; that way, the granola stays crunchy.

Good to know

Why does frozen yogurt get hard so quickly?

Because yogurt contains a lot of water and little fat. Fat coats the ice crystals and keeps them small; without it, they grow and you end up with a block instead of a mixture. Full-fat instead of low-fat yogurt, a splash of heavy cream, and enough sugar together help counteract this. Sugar also lowers the freezing point, keeping some of the liquid from freezing.

Does the yogurt really need to be drained first?

It’s not essential, but it makes a big difference. Hanging the yogurt in a cloth or in a sieve lined with a coffee filter for a few hours drains off the whey, which is exactly the thin liquid that would otherwise freeze into large crystals. What remains is thicker and firmer. If you’re already using thick Greek yogurt, you can drain it for less time.

Why do you churn it for less time than ice cream?

A yogurt base contains less fat and no egg yolk, so it thickens faster. If you keep churning, you’ll whip the cream in it into little flecks of butter, making the texture grainy instead of smooth. Stop as soon as the mixture is as thick as soft serve and falls off the spatula rather than running off it.

What’s the difference from self-serve machine fro-yo?

A machine like that keeps the mixture moving continuously at a temperature just below freezing, so it dispenses like soft serve and retains small crystals. At home, your container sits still in a much colder freezer, so it gets harder and you have to let it sit for a little while. Those machines also often use a ready-made base; here, you decide how much cream and sugar to add.

Which yogurt is best to use?

Full-fat Greek or Turkish yogurt, because it’s thicker and contains more fat than regular yogurt. Low-fat varieties make a watery base and therefore larger ice crystals. Quark works too, but it’s tangier and drier, so plan on adding a little more sugar and an extra splash of cream.

How long does it keep?

Covered, it will keep for about two weeks in the freezer, but the texture is best on day one and noticeably deteriorates after that. Store it in a shallow container with a sheet of baking paper directly on the surface to prevent it from drying out.

Frequently asked questions

What exactly is frozen yogurt?

Frozen yogurt with sugar and usually a little cream added, instead of ice cream made with cream and egg yolk. That makes it taste fresher and tangier than ice cream. Because yogurt is lower in fat, it also freezes harder, which you can counter with full-fat yogurt, a splash of cream, and enough sugar.

How do you make frozen yogurt without an ice cream maker?

First strain the yogurt, mix everything together, and put it in a shallow container in the freezer. For the first hour and a half, stir vigorously every twenty minutes to break up the crystals around the edges before they get large. A quicker option: blend frozen fruit with the strained yogurt and eat it right away as soft serve.

Why is my frozen yogurt grainy?

Usually because there’s too little fat or sugar, or sometimes because it’s churned for too long. Use full-fat yogurt, strain it, keep the cream in, and don’t cut back on the sugar, as it keeps some of the moisture liquid. Stop churning as soon as the mixture reaches the consistency of soft serve.

What toppings go well with frozen yogurt?

The classics are granola, fresh fruit, honey and chocolate. Granola adds the crunch the soft mixture lacks, fruit brings acidity and color, honey binds it together, and chocolate stays hard enough to hear. Serve them separately on the table, because they soften within a few minutes in the glasses.

Everything for your bar,
to one address

Restaurant-quality glasses, delivered as a set. Order today, delivered fast.

Shop the glasses →